Wal-Mart: A big lesson in listening
At our recent Leadership Conference, a panel examined the media messages our industry sends to consumers. Two marketing mavens, Fred Yaffe and Lance Hanish, each gave the 240-plus attendees advice on how they can put their best foot forward when reaching out to the consumer.
On the way back from our conference, I found myself wondering if our industry devotes the same energy to internal communications. My guess is that it doesn't.
And if I'm right, that's a particularly slippery slope. In fact, I'm convinced the only thing worse than a disgruntled customer is a disgruntled employee.
Of late, nobody knows that better than the Bentonville behemoth, Wal-Mart. Recently, it launched a multi-faceted internal public relations program designed to convince the company's 1.3 million U.S. employees that it really does appreciate them.
People close to the action say the program was launched to quell growing worker resentment that surfaced soon after Wal-Mart announced a number of policy changes that affected its workforce.
Some Wal-Mart workers argued the company, which is the world's largest retailer, was seeking to reduce costs by using more part-time help, scheduling more evening help and capping wages.
The bubble-over byproduct of all this unresolved angst was the formation of a group and a Web site, both called WakeUpWalMart.com, funded by a food and commercial workers union.
The Web site, which is full of information that paints Wal-Mart in a less-than-flattering light, also reports that the group has begun airing emotionally charged TV commercials featuring Wal-Mart employees talking about such things as low pay and not being able to leave the store without penalty to care for a sick child.
In the TV spots, the workers encourage viewers to tell Wal-Mart to do the right thing this holiday season, and "put America's families first."
Wow! So much for my Kodak-moment mental snapshot of Wal-Mart founder Sam Walton, driving around in a beat-up pickup truck looking for good causes to adopt. In today's competitive market, you not only want buzz, you need it. You just don't want the buzz saw.
My advice to company executives: Make it a point to hear what your employees are saying about your company. I'll bet you can hear a pin drop in Bentonville these days.
JD, Mt. Holly, NC commented:
This is no place to beat up on Wal-Mart, so I am not going to do that, except to say this. A relative of mine worked for Wal-Mart so I can tell you that the policies recently enacted with employees were indeed designed to reduce employment costs for Wal-Mart. I am a company executive too and can spot a "flying Doo-Doo" a long way off. Wal-Mart should have been taken to task for it---not for what they did, but because they failed to stand up and admit honestly what the effect of the policies would be. There is a lot of dishonesty at Wal-Mart these days.
Their present "push" practices with their vendors these days is horrifying. Does Wal-Mart not realize that as more manufacturing is relegated to China, there will come a day when China may decide to patriate all industry and China will own the American economy (if it doesn't already)? You think it can't happen? Think about it! Hide and watch!






















